Showing posts with label Allen County GOP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Allen County GOP. Show all posts

Friday, January 11, 2008

Alleged Illegal GOP Caucus Didn't Happen

Allen County Democratic Party Chairman Kevin Knuth reports that the Republican Party held a possibly illegal caucus at councilman Don Schmidt's house in 2007 to discuss the city's upcoming budget vote:
It has been reported to me that all the Republican members of City Council met at Don Schmidt's home to discuss the proposed budget. This would be a legal caucus....except they were joined by Council Legislative Affairs Administrator Molly McCray and one of the City Council attorneys. These folks are paid with TAXPAYER dollars and should not be considered part of a POLITICAL caucus.

Since a majority of the council was at this meeting, and since it may not be qualified as a caucus, and since they discussed the city budget, it is unclear to me if they budget we now have is legal or not.

I'm not sure who Knuth's source is but former councilman Sam Talarico has informed me that he was at no such meeting and hasn't been to Schmidt's house in five years. I also contacted Molly McCray and asked her to confirm this and she told me she has no knowledge of any such meeting taking place. I've also been told that council attorney Joe Bonahoom was not at any such meeting either. So if this meeting did take place it sounds like it was in fact a legal caucus and we have a legal budget...

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Supreme Court Reprimands Steve Shine

Local Republican chairman Steve Shine was in the news today as the JG reports that the state Supreme Court has issued him a reprimand for the way his wife handled funds at his law firm.
The Indiana Supreme Court issued a private reprimand to local attorney Steve Shine for misconduct related to financial oversight at his law firm.

The reprimand was issued because for five months beginning in May 2005, Beth Shine, Steve Shine’s wife, wrote approximately 11 checks to herself or to accounts to which she had access from the law firm’s trust account, according to the court documents. This amounted to misappropriating $22,257 in client money without the knowledge of anyone at the firm, Shine & Hardin

However, the paper reports that all the money was paid back in late 2005...

Friday, August 24, 2007

Former Republican Vice Chair Supports Tom Henry

I mentioned this in a previous post but the Indiana News Center now has a story up I can link to:
Cathy Hawks/Former GOP Vice Chair: "I would count my loss in this mayor's race. I would extend my hand of congratulation to Tom Henry, he loves this community, he has been an honest and upstanding citizen, let's let him run the city for four years and see how he does. Our option is Kelty or Henry. I'll be supporting Tom Henry.

Especially in light of recent events/comments, I think Cathy Hawks is making a wise decision in supporting Tom Henry...

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Republican Chairman Eliminates Executive Committee Due to Kelty Infighting

The JG is reporting that Steve Shine has dissolved the Republican Party's executive committee:
Allen County Republican Chairman Steve Shine on Thursday dissolved the party’s executive committee, the day its president resigned because of concerns about Matt Kelty’s mayoral candidacy.

Shine said he would announce the committee’s elimination to county precinct officials Thursday evening. The group of about 200 precinct officials were scheduled to meet to discuss Kelty’s legal problems.

Shine said he decided to eliminate the group because its members were using it as a forum to get publicity for party infighting.

“The committee has become a public platform for people on both sides of this matter,” he said. “Regrettably, it has become a vehicle for discord rather than one for accord.”

Shine’s announcement comes just hours after Ken Neumeister, the president of the committee and an influential GOP fundraiser, resigned because of his unhappiness with the party’s support for Kelty.

Of course this was probably just a preemptive strike by Shine because Mike Sylvester reported that a 2nd person resigned from the board and that more were likely to follow...

Matt Kelty Lies In WANE Television Interview

From day one of this campaign finance fiasco I have said that Matt Kelty violated the law. However, I have also said that I have no reason to think that Kelty is anything but an honest person that made a mistake. As of today, I can no longer make that statement in good conscience. His WANE interview from yesterday has put me over the top.

I'm going to have another post later detailing numerous other absurd comments made by Kelty in this interview but I wanted to put this up first. I wanted to put this up because this lie is so blatant that frankly I can't believe he even has the chutzpah to make it. Kelty's behavior reminds me of a 10 year old child that simply can't own up to the mistake he's made and instead decides to deny the truth at every opportunity. I have not rushed to judgement on this and I debated how I wanted to handle his comments. I try not to attack people personally but at the end of the day, Matt Kelty has struck me as a dishonest person and I can no longer suggest anything different.

I'm 100% positive that many will disagree with me on this and will probably even attack me for making such comments. However, those that know me realize that I am not a reactionary and partisan person. I am extremely disappointed in Matt Kelty and the false statements he made during the WANE interview. Here is the exchange (at the 7:30 mark) that finally drove me over the edge - readers can decide for themselves:

Mellinger: Has anyone in the Republican party, a higher up, talked with you, broached the suggestion of stepping out of the race?

Kelty: No.

Mellinger: It's never happened? Steve Shine never said anything to you? Nobody on the executive committee?

Kelty: No

Mellinger: You're saying that since the primary nobody has said 'Matt Kelty it's a good idea to get out of this'?

Kelty: My memory is always a little spotty but I don't recall anybody asking me directly or even insinuating that I should get out of the race.

This is a 100% lie and everybody knows it. Notice how he hedges by talking about his "spotty memory" when Mellinger continues to press the question. He didn't believe his answer and he was giving Kelty a chance to explain - he never does. There is no way you forget someone asking or insinuating that you drop out of the race. For him to make such a statement when asked repeatedly shows what a dishonest response this was.

More on the interview later...

Resignation Letter from GOP Executive Committee President

Wane has the story up and I've posted Neumeister's resignation letter below:
Re: Resignation from Executive Committee

Steve:

Please accept this as my official resignation as President and Member of the Executive Committee of the Republican Party of Allen County. After serving on the Executive Committee since its inception 7 1/2 years ago, I can not support the direction the party is taking regarding the Matt Kelty situation.

I will continue to work for and serve our other Republican candidates and elected office holders, as I have done for the past 15 years.

Sincerely,

Kenneth R. Neumeister

Ouch...

GOP Executive Committee Does Not Support Matt Kelty

Despite Steve Shine's outrage about information leaking out of the executive committee meetings, I've been told about the lack of support Matt Kelty received in their last meeting. I think it's important to point out that the executive committee is simply an advisory board set up by the party chairman and has no actual authority and there was no official vote taken.

Having said that, I have it from a reliable source that if you had to classify those that did not want to support Kelty going forward vs those that did want to support him - the "vote" would be 18-6 against supporting Kelty.

When I attempted to confirm this with another source I was told that it was difficult to put everyone's statements into such a black-and-white position. They told me that feelings toward Matt's candidacy ranged from complete and total support to he's a liar and should be thrown out of party headquarters.

Although the 2nd source wouldn't confirm the 18-6 number I think it's safe to say that Kelty does not have a lot of support within the executive committee...

Head of GOP Executive Committee to Resign Over Kelty Fiasco

I had it from a Republican official that the head of the Allen County executive committee was to resign today because he did not want to support Matt Kelty.

While in the process of making this post I was told that the Indiana News Center has just broken the story that Ken Neumeister is stepping down. Looks like I was about 5 minutes late.

I was also told that the report states that Cathy Hawks is now publicly supporting Nelson Peters Tom Henry.

It's not up on their website yet but when it is I'll link to it...

Update: Looks like Mike Sylvester already had a post up on this.

Monday, June 04, 2007

Fort Wayne GOP Continues to Undermine Kelty Campaign

Many of you may remember this post where I suggested that there were sinister motives behind certain members of the Allen County GOP "helping" Matt Kelty by suggesting he update his campaign finance report to reflect $160k in loans. Local Republican blogger (and Kelty supporter) AWB has the goods and sends a letter to Republican Party Chair Steve Shine:

Matt has done everything you and the four horsemen of the apocalypse (Neumeister, Bodenhafer, Jaggers, and Bean) have asked and more.

The motives, intent, and actions behind this whole theater of deceit is the worst kept secret in Fort Wayne. Matt has supporters in every circle and they are reporting open discussions by Party officials and “fixers” about how they pulled a fast one on Matt and how they can’t wait to get Peters on the ballot.

He is trying to remain loyal to the Party, and you are repaying his loyalty by violating his trust. At the end of the day, Matt won the old fashion way, he got more votes. He did it with less money, without the support of the Party, with a message and vision that resonated with voters, and by working harder. He will do it again if he has to. You are going to have to convict him, because he will not quit.

Is the suicide pact you’ve entered into with the horsemen to keep Kelty off the ballot worth destroying the Party?

Wow.

I have been an avid critic of Kelty's decision to withhold the source of his loans but I said then and I will reiterate now - Matt Kelty should respect the will of the voters and not drop out of the race. If anyone should step down it is Steve Shine...

Saturday, May 26, 2007

The REAL Reason the Kelty Loan Issue Is Surfacing Now

It's fairly unusual for a political party to throw its own nominee to the wolves, but that appears to be what is happening here. Matt Kelty has already admitted that it was people within the Republican party that wanted him to clarify the source of the loans. The problem I have with all this is why wasn't it done before the primary election? These loans came about in 2006 and there have been rumblings around town about them for months - so why now? Allen County Republican chair Steve Shine answered that question in today's JG:
Shine said it wasn’t the party’s role to question legitimate candidates about their campaigns during a primary because it could be construed as the party taking a side in the race.

Give me a break. Is he insinuating that the party didn't take Peters' side in the primary? I don't think there's a single voter that believes that. Regardless, why wouldn't the party provide guidance to ALL their candidates so everything is above board? I'll tell you why they didn't, because they've had SO MANY ethical lapses lately that they simply hoped that Nelson Peters would win and the issue would go away.

Only now, after an unwanted Kelty victory, are they coming out to "help" Kelty make sure everything he does is transparent. What's really transparent is that some within the Republican party are attempting to sell Matt Kelty down the river. If they can stir up enough controversy then perhaps they can get him to step down before the July 15 deadline required by election law (IC 3-8-7-28). If so, then a caucus of precinct committeemen get to fill the vacancy - who do you think they would pick?

In my opinion it's quite unprecedented for members of a political party to try and sabotage their own nominee's campaign. I guess they can't get over the fact that voters in this community wanted the party to go in a different direction. Matt Kelty should accept the will of the voters and reject these underhanded attempts by those in his own party hoping to force his withdrawal...

Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Steve Shine Should Step Down as GOP Chair

The Allen County Republican party has had it's share of ethical lapses (see here, here and here). Perhaps it's debatable about whether these problems were caused by a failure of leadership or not. However, after yesterday's election what is certainly not debatable is that Steve Shine no longer represents the voters of his party.

Personally, I don't think either party should endorse candidates in the primary. The idea of party-building is to promote all your candidates and let the membership decide who they want to represent the party. But if you do go out on a limb and support a primary candidate, then you had better be damn sure they will win because a loss completely undermines your presence within the party.

Shine lined up nearly every county-wide elected official to support Peters. He got Congressman Mark Souder to endorse him. He also had state-wide officials holding fundraisers and supporting him - in essence, he bet the farm...and lost.

In yesterday's vote the party membership not only rejected Nelson Peters but also Shine's leadership. They refused to follow his lead and with their votes they let him know they wanted the party to move in a new direction. He can no longer claim to be an effective leader within his own party.

Steve Shine should accept the will of the voters and resign...